Customer Contracts and Cyber Essentials: Do MSPs Need a Penetration Test?

By EJN Labs · 12 Nov 2026 · 9 min read

No public rule makes a customer contract or security schedule require a penetration test from a managed service provider. The clause is private to you and your customer. In our experience it asks for Cyber Essentials, often at the Plus level, and sometimes for an independent test of your own tooling as well. Cyber Essentials Plus is an audit, not a penetration test, and neither tier requires one.

Does a customer contract require a managed service provider to have a penetration test?

Only if that contract says so. No law or published standard that we can point you to makes a test compulsory for an MSP. The requirement lives in the customer’s master services agreement, security schedule or supplier questionnaire, and each customer words it differently. Read the clause before you commission anything.

MSPs are asked more often than most suppliers because of what the tooling can reach. The management console, the remote monitoring platform, the help desk and the backup system give your staff privileged access into every customer you support. A customer’s security team knows that one compromised console can reach many environments at once, so the contract tends to ask about your tooling as well as your office.

The NCSC’s cloud security guidance makes the same point from the buyer’s side. Its Principle 3, separation between customers, says that to gain confidence in separation controls you should look for “externally audited evidence of regular penetration tests”. That is guidance for buyers, not a mandate, but it is the sort of sentence that ends up in a customer’s security schedule.

What does a security schedule actually ask for?

Contract schedules are private, and there is no public template for MSPs to quote. In our experience the clause takes one of three forms: a requirement to hold Cyber Essentials or Cyber Essentials Plus, a requirement to commission an independent penetration test at stated intervals, or a general duty to maintain appropriate security and provide evidence on request.

  • Cyber Essentials or Cyber Essentials Plus. Customers who hold the certification themselves often ask their suppliers to hold it too. The NCSC describes the Plus tier as the same protections as Cyber Essentials “but with more rigorous independent technical testing”. It is an assessor-led technical audit of devices and settings. Neither tier requires a penetration test, and the certificate alone does not answer a clause that asks for one. See our page on Cyber Essentials Plus.
  • An independent penetration test. A tester tries to break into a defined system and reports what they found. When the clause says “independent penetration test” or “security test of the service”, this is the evidence to send, and the scope should include the tooling that touches customer environments.
  • A general duty with evidence on request. A short pack of the certificate, the latest test letter and a retest note answers most of these.

When the wording is unclear, ask the customer’s security contact whether the clause means the certificate, a test report, or both. Also check the interval. A clause that says “annually” is easier to plan for than one that says “regularly”.

Which public rules sit behind the request?

One public rule applies to an MSP that handles customer data, and it does not name a penetration test. UK GDPR Article 32(1)(d) requires a process for regularly testing, assessing and evaluating the effectiveness of your security measures. It does not name penetration testing as the method.

It reaches MSPs because they usually act as processors for their customers. The ICO’s data security guide notes that the security requirements “also apply to data processors”. The same guide says testing can be done through techniques such as vulnerability scanning and penetration testing, which is a list of options, not an instruction. See our page on GDPR penetration testing.

Who can carry out the test?

Customer contracts seldom name an accreditation, and where one does, use the one it names. MSPs and technology suppliers can use a CREST-accredited company or a CHECK provider, depending on what their requirement states. EJN Labs is CREST-accredited. If the clause is silent, a CREST-accredited company is a sensible default.

CHECK is the scheme under which NCSC assured companies can conduct authorised penetration tests of public sector and CNI systems and networks. If your customer is a public body and the clause names CHECK, use a provider approved for it. For a commercial customer, a requirement naming CHECK would be unusual.

Ask two practical questions of any tester. Which legal entity holds the accreditation, and can you see it on the scheme’s own register. And how will testing be kept away from real customer data, because the safe set-up is a test tenant or a small number of representative customer environments, agreed in writing.

What should a managed service provider test?

Test the tooling that gives your staff access into customer environments, because that is the part a customer’s clause is really about. Customer separation is the main question: can a compromised console account, agent or session reach another customer? A test needs at least two customer environments with distinct privileged roles to answer it properly.

  • PSA and customer management console. Customer-to-customer separation, staff permission boundaries, and what a compromised account can see or change.
  • Remote monitoring and management. Console authentication, agent and update integrity, and whether a session can pivot from one customer’s endpoints into another’s network.
  • Help desk and ticketing. Cross-customer ticket visibility, attachment access, and secrets left in ticket notes.
  • Multi-tenant Microsoft 365 and Entra ID administration. Delegated admin permissions, conditional access gaps and what a compromised MSP account can reach inside a customer tenant.
  • Backup and recovery platforms. Cross-customer restore access, immutability and retention settings.
  • Client networks and Active Directory. Privileged access paths and segregation between your management tooling and the customer’s own network. See internal network penetration testing.

What evidence do you hand back to the customer?

Hand back what the clause asks for. A dated summary letter naming the scope, the testing company and the outcome usually satisfies a security schedule, with the full report available under a confidentiality agreement. The report describes weaknesses in tooling that every customer depends on, so share it only where a confidentiality agreement is in place. This is practice, not a rule.

Pair the letter with the Cyber Essentials certificate and the retest confirmation. Together they show a customer three different things: your devices meet a baseline, your tooling was tested by an outsider, and the serious findings were fixed. Keep the scope document too, so you can show which tools and which customer separation scenarios the test covered.

What does it cost?

Price follows the number of testing days, and the number of days follows the scope. UK day rates for CREST-accredited penetration testing typically run £1,100 to £1,400. The pricing page shows typical engagement lengths for each type of test, and the quote form gives an exact figure for your scope.

How EJN Labs approaches testing for managed service providers

EJN Labs is a CREST-accredited UK penetration testing company with a dedicated managed service provider service. We test the tooling that gives your staff privileged access into every customer you support: the PSA and customer management console, the RMM and remote-access platform, the help desk and ticketing system, multi-tenant Microsoft 365 and Entra ID administration, and the backup platform.

You provide a designated test tenant, a staging console or a small number of representative customer environments, and we agree in writing what stays out of scope before testing starts. Testing is safe by default on production, with no denial of service, and out of hours slots are available. EJN Labs is also an IASME Certification Body for Cyber Essentials and Cyber Essentials Plus.

The work is done by UK-based, CREST-certified testers. You get a fixed price for a defined scope, findings in a client portal, CVSS-scored findings with a walkthrough call, and the report on the last day of testing. Retests are free until findings are resolved, and there are no out-of-hours, callout, cancellation or rescheduling fees.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Cyber Essentials Plus count as a penetration test?

No. Cyber Essentials Plus is an assessor-led technical audit of your devices and settings, and neither tier requires a penetration test. If your customer contract asks for an independent penetration test, the certificate alone will not answer it, and a test report does not replace the certificate.

Does a customer contract have to name a penetration test?

No. No public rule requires it. Each customer writes its own security schedule, which is private. In our experience some ask for Cyber Essentials, some for an independent test of your tooling, and some for evidence on request. Read the clause and ask the customer which evidence they need.

What does the NCSC say about penetration testing for managed services?

NCSC Cloud Security Principle 3 says buyers should look for externally audited evidence of regular penetration tests when assessing separation between customers. It is guidance for buyers, not a mandate, but customers often reflect it in their security schedules when they buy a managed service.

Does the testing company need to be CREST-accredited or a CHECK provider?

Contracts seldom name one. MSPs and technology suppliers can use a CREST-accredited company or a CHECK provider, depending on what their requirement states. EJN Labs is CREST-accredited. Use the accreditation your customer or internal standard names, and ask them if it is not stated.

Can a penetration test run against real customer environments?

It does not need to. The safe set-up is a designated test tenant, a staging console or a small number of representative customer environments, with what stays out of scope agreed in writing before testing starts. Customers should be told if any of their environments are used.

Get a quote for your managed service provider

Tell us which tools are in scope and which customer clause has asked for the evidence. Request a fixed-price quote and we will come back with the number of days, the price and the earliest start date.

Related: Penetration Testing Cost for UK Managed Service Providers, Best Penetration Testing Companies for UK Managed Service Providers, penetration testing for UK managed service providers, Cyber Essentials Plus, GDPR penetration testing and Cyber Essentials.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *